How to Check Holiday Price Claims Before You Advertise

Back-turned shop manager sorting unmarked price tags at a wooden counter in warm window light

A holiday price claims review shows whether a Black Friday or Cyber Monday discount is real before the ad goes live. You will learn how to prove a former price, separate it from a compare-at or list price, and lock shipping, rain-check, and exclusion language. Those sales fall on Nov. 27 and Nov. 30, and a Rocket Lawyer briefing says deceptive pricing laws cover was/now prices, doorbusters, and limited-time offers.

Updated November 17, 2026

Key Takeaways

  • Black Friday is Nov. 27; Cyber Monday is Nov. 30.
  • A former price must be an open, regular public offer.
  • Be reasonably certain a compare-at price does not exceed substantial trade-area sales.
  • Have a reasonable basis for any advertised ship date.

What should you prove before a was/now claim?

The FTC’s Guides Against Deceptive Pricing allow a former-price comparison only if that price is the actual, bona fide price offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time. Laura Bojart’s Rocket Lawyer briefing says that otherwise the bargain is made up, and that a one-week price will not do.

A $40 early-November increase advertised as 35% off is the fake markdown it flags. Some states set a stricter duration, so check them.

No sales at the higher price do not, alone, make it fictitious. It still must have been an open, active offer in the recent, regular course of business, made in good faith.

Avoid “Formerly sold at” unless substantial sales occurred. If the ad says only “Sale,” the reduction cannot be meaningless. “Reduced to $9.99” from $10 is the guides’ example of a misleading nominal cut.

How should holiday price claims treat a compare-at price?

A compare-at or list price is not your former price. Rocket Lawyer says it should be close to what shoppers in your area actually pay, not a sticker nobody charges.

The guides say you should be reasonably certain the higher price does not appreciably exceed the price at which substantial sales of the article are being made in the trade area. That is the legal test, not a rule that the compare-at price must track those sales.

Claim Reference price What to keep
Was/now Your own former offer Records of a regular, open public price
Compare-at Prevailing trade-area price Support that it does not appreciably exceed substantial sales in the trade area
Comparable value Like-grade goods nearby Similar quality, clearly disclosed, obtainable locally

If a number of the principal retail outlets regularly sell at $10, “Price Elsewhere $10, Our Price $7.50” is not dishonest. That is the guides’ example of a non-deceptive comparison, not the record standard itself.

“Retail Value $15.00, My Price $7.50” is deceptive when only a few small suburban outlets charge $15 and the larger outlets charge $7.50, or slightly more or less. State a buy-one-get-one catch in the ad, such as a same-size rule or a Sunday end date. The guides say the terms should be clear from the start.

What should you lock before ads go live?

On Oct. 26, 2026, the FTC and 20 states sued Dollar General, alleging customers were charged more at the register than prices on shelves, tags, and ads. Arnold & Porter notes the complaint alleges at least 29,265 “Did Not Honor Marked Price” complaints from Jan. 1, 2023, through March 31, 2026.

For small sellers already tracking an October inflation squeeze, the practical reading is to match the ad, the page, and checkout, and to document the check.

  1. Review price history for every item you plan to discount, and save what you charged and when.
  2. Put exclusions, limits, and the return policy in plain language, close to the offer.
  3. The FTC’s Guides Against Bait Advertising say not to advertise a product unless you can meet reasonably expected demand, unless the ad clearly says supply is limited.
  4. “only 25 in stock” helps set expectations but does not automatically make a misleading offer acceptable. Check your state’s rain-check rules.
  5. Have a reasonable basis to believe you can ship by any date you advertise. If you give no date, the default is 30 days after receiving the order.
  6. On a delay, you generally must notify the customer and give a choice to wait or get a refund. Check the warehouse or carrier first.
  7. Cover price errors, rain checks, and cancellations in your terms, and have a second person check prices before ads go out.

How do fee rules affect advertised prices?

The FTC Fees Rule, effective May 2025, is limited to live-event ticketing and short-term lodging. Kirkland says FTC guidance still treats omitted mandatory fees as a possible Section 5 problem more broadly.

It lists some form of all-in pricing law in California, Minnesota, Oregon, Connecticut, Virginia, Massachusetts, and Colorado.

Frequently asked questions

When are Black Friday and Cyber Monday?

Black Friday is Nov. 27 and Cyber Monday is Nov. 30, and deceptive pricing laws apply to was/now claims, doorbusters, and limited-time offers.

How long must a former price have been offered?

It must be a price offered openly and regularly for a reasonable time, not a one-week price.

Do I have to honor a mistaken holiday price?

That depends on your state, your terms, and when you accepted the order. A term delaying acceptance until shipment may allow cancellation of a $200 jacket posted at $20.

What if an ad states no shipping date?

The default is 30 days after you receive the order. On a delay, you generally must let the customer wait or get a refund.

Notice an error?

Help us improve our content by reporting any issues you find.